Mercuryo - Sponsor Image Mercuryo - Infrastructure powering the crypto economy. Friend & Sponsor Learn more

Bitcoin's Ordinals War Reaches Its Verdict

A weekend soft fork aimed at restricting NFTs on Bitcoin collapsed after two blocks.
Bitcoin's Ordinals War Reaches Its Verdict
Listen
0
0
0:00 0:00

Subscribe to Bankless or sign in

Bitcoin's trading in the green on the week, which is notable, as this performance came in the face of Michael Saylor's Strategy selling another +$100M chunk of BTC between Aug. 3rd and Aug. 9th.

The OG coin has been undeterred. Yet sell pressure isn't the only thing Bitcoin has shrugged off in recent days. The network's war over NFT "spam" seems to have finally ended, and in favor of the NFTers.

I previously wrote about this intensifying schism last October, when Bitcoin Core's v30 release reignited the fight over whether Ordinals, Runes, and other "non-monetary" data belonged onchain.

Back then, the forking talk from Ordinals critics was still just talk. This past weekend, it became a short-lived fork attempt.

This effort was dubbed BIP-110, a proposed soft fork meant to restrict non-financial data in Bitcoin transactions. It needed 55% miner signaling to lock in, though it only got roughly 2.5%. Nodes backing BIP-110 split off from the main chain this past Saturday, mined two blocks, then stalled out while Bitcoin proper pulled dozens of blocks ahead.

Enjoying this article?

Subscribe to Bankless or sign in

It's true that even if BIP-110 was successful, it wouldn't have been that effective at stopping Ordinals and the like. But what has been established is the lack of consensus for policing Bitcoin's blockspace in this way. BIP-110 was an opportunity for change, yet the vast majority of the Bitcoin community demonstrated they don't want that type of change.

So is the fight done? Surely some in the BIP-110 faction will try to muster up a new response later. Whether that retry would be any more successful remains to be seen. It seems entirely likely that this failed fork over the weekend will be the high-water mark of this movement. So there may be more chapters to come here, yes, but the biggest fireworks may be over.

In contrast, there is another planned fork coming up that isn't trying to vie for dominance of Bitcoin but rather to break out as an entirely new experiment. That project is eCash, and it's rolling out in phases through Oct. 31st. It will be an independent chain snapshotted from Bitcoin's ledger but recentered around Drivechains.

That said, eCash has taken the opposite approach compared to BIP-110. Instead of imposing new rules on Bitcoin from within, it's just leaving and building its own space next door.

Of course, the BIP-110ers are free to do the same if they truly can't stomach NFTs atop Bitcoin. The choice is theirs, as the Bitcoin community has already made its decision too. The NFTs are staying.


William M. Peaster

Written by William M. Peaster

1027 Articles View all      

William M. Peaster, Senior Writer, has been with Bankless since January 2021. Immersed in Ethereum since 2017, he covers the onchain frontier with a particular interest in art, games, and other culture apps. He has a background in creative writing and writes fiction in his free time.

No Responses
Rechercher sur Bankless