The DeFi Report - Sponsor Image The DeFi Report - Industry-leading crypto research trusted by finance pros. Friend & Sponsor Learn more


🔒 FREE PREVIEW: Upgrade to unlock full access. Join Bankless Premium.

Prediction Markets Face Full-Court Press
Published on May 1, 2026

Sponsor: MetaMask - Spend crypto anywhere online and AFK with MetaMask MetaMask Card.

.  .  .
NEED TO KNOW
Paradigm's Quantum Solution?

  1. 🤯 Paradigm Paradigm Proposes PACTs to Address Bitcoin's Quantum Vulnerabilities. The proposed fix still involves irrevocably burning funds of quantum-vulnerable addresses that fail to take action.
  2. 💰 Tether Tether Publishes Reserve Attestation for Q1 2026. The world's largest digital asset issuer claims to have made $1.04B in net profit last quarter.
  3. 🇰🇷 South Korean Court Stays Six-Month Bithumb Suspension. The peninsular nation's financial watchdog imposed a $24.6M fine and partial business suspension on Bithumb last month.
📸
Daily Market Snapshot: April was the best month for stocks since 2020 as stock markets ripped to all-time highs shrugging off Iran War uncertainty. With BTC up 14% on the month, crypto isn't looking too bad either.
Prices as of 5pm ET 24hr 7d
Crypto $2.59T ↗ 1.8% ↘ 0.1%
BTC $77,960 ↗ 2.1% ↗ 0.4%
ETH $2,288 ↗ 1.3% ↘ 1.3%

.  .  .
OPINION
Prediction Markets Face a Full-Court Press
Bankless Author: David Christopher

Prediction markets have been facing an awfully tough moment in recent weeks.

  • The platforms continue to face headlines that underscore the complexity of preventing insider trading from breaking trust in its markets. The U.S. Senate just banned Senators from trading on the platforms at all. Meanwhile, governors from Illinois, New York, and Maryland banned state employees from trading on these platforms. This all comes after the DOJ indicted a sergeant who allegedly used classified intelligence to win over $400K on a Polymarket bet.
  • Meanwhile, states are continuing to challenge their most profitable venue: sports wagers. Wisconsin’s attorney general sued five platforms on unlicensed gambling grounds. New York’s AG sued two more on the same theory and joined with 38 other state AGs to back Massachusetts in its case against Kalshi.

While platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket are fighting back with mixed success, critics argue that the platforms are practically indistinguishable from sports gambling and are exploiting gaps between federal regulation and state gambling laws. The massive upside potential for these platforms will require winning the legal battles ahead while also challenging negative sentiment around prediction market integrity.

Sports Supremacy

The 2024 Presidential election may have sold the world on prediction markets' promise, but betting on sports has increasingly become the top entry point for users.

Kalshi cleared over $23 billion in trading volume in 2025. Roughly 86% of that activity was tied to sports. Polymarket reportedly cleared $10 billion in sports trading volume in Q1 of this year alone – its most popular category by far.

via Dune | @datadashboards

The platforms are seeing huge volumes and are getting key institutional buy-in too.

The growth potential of sports-related prediction markets has been a key area of investor excitement; Kalshi and Polymarket have already raised billions of dollars in venture capital funding.

The NHL signed multi-year deals with both Kalshi and Polymarket last October. Then came the UFC the following month. In January, MLS partnered with Polymarket and in March MLB signed an exclusive deal with them, reportedly worth up to $300 million over three years. The NBA is reportedly in active talks with both platforms, too.

Prediction markets are reckoning with a battle between federal regulators and state officials over jurisdiction. While sports gambling is regulated at the state level, financial swaps are regulated federally, and the entire dispute comes down to which bucket Kalshi and Polymarket's sports contracts fall into. The platforms say they are swaps. A number of states say these platforms are simply a new venue for sports gambling.

Complicating the position is the fact that Kalshi has argued both sides of this question. Back in 2023, while fighting the CFTC's attempt to block election markets, Kalshi argued that elections weren't "gaming" because elections aren't games. Football games, the company conceded at the time, were. They're now arguing the opposite, and states have been quoting that contradiction back at them in court.

The legal substance hinges on a single phrase in Dodd-Frank, which requires a swap to track a real financial, economic, or commercial outcome. Kalshi argues events like Super Bowl outcomes qualify because billions in advertising, travel, and merchandise depend on them. States argue that logic stretches the statute past its breaking point, and that if the Super Bowl counts, almost any event does.

Did Prediction Markets Win the Super Bowl? on Bankless
Prediction markets may not have outright dominated the Super Bowl, but data suggests growing pressure on sportsbooks.

For now, the courts haven't agreed on which reading wins. The Third Circuit appellate court, the highest level court that has tried cases involving prediction markets, sided with Kalshi in early April. The Ninth Circuit, a court at the same level, heard arguments soon after and it appears likely things could go the other way. A circuit split usually pulls the Supreme Court in, but even SCOTUS isn't the final word here, because the dispute is over how to read a law that Congress wrote and Congress can rewrite the law at any point, a process already in motion.

The recently introduced Prediction Markets Are Gambling Act would tighten the swap definition so sports and event contracts fall outside of it, mooting the current legal fight entirely. Whether a bill like this has the votes with an industry-friendly administration in place is an open question. But the Polymarket for "Law banning sports prediction markets enacted in 2026?" currently only gives an 11% chance of passage.

If Congress doesn't move, the case could very well head to the Supreme Court. A win for the platforms undermines most state lawsuits while a loss forces them into navigating gaming systems state-by-state. But, the reality is that even a SCOTUS win wouldn't settle things permanently. A more prediction market-hostile Congress could rewrite the swap definition later, and the only move left at that point would be a constitutional challenge, arguing the law itself violates the Constitution or goes beyond what Congress is allowed to regulate – a much harder path.

It's far from a straightforward road ahead, even with an administration whose officials continue to publicly advocate for the platforms.

Winning Public Opinion

What gets lost in all this is what prediction markets actually do better than the alternative. 

State gaming laws largely exist to protect customers from operators running platforms engineered to beat the customer over time. With Prediction markets, price emerges from peer-to-peer trades and the platform's only job is matching them. It banks plenty of profits off of these trading volumes, but the underlying market design means that a retail user on Kalshi or Polymarket isn't fundamentally competing against a counterparty designed to extract from them.

This isn't the easiest message to sell to an audience that seems to largely take issue with prediction markets tacitly encouraging a behavior that they believe should be more greatly controlled. Add in broad distrust with the underlying fairness of Wall Street (and Crypto!) and those insider trading scandals could transform regulating these platforms into an irresistibly populist pursuit for more lawmakers.

Prediction markets aren’t built like traditional sportsbooks, but that nuance may matter less than how they’re perceived. Their long-term trajectory will likely depend on whether they can clearly communicate that difference to the public and regulators.

A First-Principles Defense of Prediction Markets on Bankless
Prediction markets are markets. Markets should be regulated at the federal level.

FRIEND & SPONSOR: METAMASK

Spend crypto online or IRL directly from your crypto wallet at over 150 million merchants worldwide—anywhere Mastercard is accepted. This is how you offramp: 3% cashback, zero foreign transaction fees, and exclusive benefits. Keep full custody of your funds until the moment you pay. Get the MetaMask Virtual Card now, free.

.  .  .
EARLY ACCESS
“Finding Satoshi”

🔒 Premium-Only! Upgrade to unlock full access. Join Bankless Premium.

Bill Cohan and Tyler Maroney unpack their new documentary Finding Satoshi, a four-year investigation into the identity of Satoshi Nakamoto.

They explore why Satoshi’s identity still matters, the cypherpunk roots of Bitcoin, the public interest behind the mystery, and what the search reveals about privacy, money, power, and the mythology at the heart of crypto.

Watch the full episode in Early Access👇


No Responses

Not financial or tax advice. Bankless content is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This newsletter is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.

Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this newsletter to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless team hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA.

Read Bankless in: English - Spanish - German - French

Not financial or tax advice. Bankless content is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This newsletter is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.

Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this newsletter to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless team hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA.

Search Bankless