Inside the episode
Ryan:
[0:04] Bankless nation it is the third week of november 2025 it is time for the bankless weekly roll-up we've got extreme fear in the crypto markets is it time to call this a bear market
David:
[0:15] What did you do while i was gone i am significantly more poor versus the last time i was here.
Ryan:
[0:21] Man i was trying to hold down the fort but it wasn't going well but i thought
Ryan:
[0:25] But you were supposed to do some damage to some of the evildoers in the mountains. I did my part. You did? So where you been? You're in Argentina right now, right?
David:
[0:37] I'm in Buenos Aires. Yes, that's right. The last two weeks I was hiking around and climbing around the Patagonia. I just got a little bit of a jumpstart of Argentina explorations ahead of DevConnect. So still waiting on the final tally of number of people that actually came to Buenos Aires. I don't think we'll ever really get the true number, but estimations are somewhere between like 7 and 11,000 people in Buenos Aires. When you take an Uber around, it takes a while for you to get one. And then when you get in an Uber, the Uber is blowing up like the driver. He's blowing up with next Uber requests. And so you can just see like crypto people just like requesting Uber after Uber. And that's how you kind of know that this city is saturated. But vibes are pretty good. it's been a great place to be people love Buenos Aires and the energy is pretty high here are.
Ryan:
[1:26] You an Argentinian yet? have you got your citizenship?
David:
[1:31] According to Fede from Land to Class I am I checked the box of being culturally Argentine look I actually want to shout out Morpho and this brand new piece of swag that I want to show off I'm going to go get it real quick one sec, I got this custom mate cup, I don't think you know what mate is right, But it's a very, very polished mate cup with a very cool spoon. It's probably, this is probably an all-time piece of swag for me. A mate is a very culturally Argentine. It's like a, it's kind of like a tea if tea was 10 times stronger. It's everyone in Argentina drinks mate. I have a cool branded mate cup from Morpho.
Ryan:
[2:11] Do you put milk in that? Or you just drink it black?
David:
[2:14] Blasphemy. Blasphemy. No, you put a bunch of herbs in it. Uh, and you've, you know how you have like a little herbal bag for your tea? Yeah. No, no, no, no. You dump herbs in so the cup is full.
Ryan:
[2:26] Wow. So it's kind of got a, not a liquid texture, not. It's totally liquid. It's got some herb kind of things floating in your mouth and your teeth.
David:
[2:34] The spoon has a filter. Ah. Yeah. Yeah. So you don't drink the herbs, but it's just extremely herby and it's extremely caffeinated. It's Yerba Mate. It's Yerba Mate. This is the original Argentine version.
Ryan:
[2:46] I want to get more of your takes on Argentina, but also, of course,
Ryan:
[2:49] DevConnect. Is Ethereum back on track? That's what I saw. But I want to get your on the ground, the vibes. You also got to give me some updates on the Bankless Summit.
David:
[2:58] Bankless Summit was awesome.
Ryan:
[2:59] Yeah, back to the extreme fear we're all feeling right now. I've got three takes from crypto investors for you on the bear market, plus some of our own. I want to get your takes too. And what else are we covering today?
David:
[3:13] The Aave app, that's definitely a topic that's been buzzing around the streets of Buenos Aires. Aave released a new consumer-friendly app to deposit stables. Well, actually, for consumers to deposit money, it gets transferred to stables in the background. And can collect somewhere between a 6% and 9% yield. So a very consumer-friendly app, which is part of one of the themes of DevConnect is consumer-friendly blockchain hiding applications. And then also inside of the Ethereum layer two space, we're talking about layer twos again, but this one's a uniquely different, Ethereum's answer to Zcash. We have a ZK layer two launching that has launched this last week out of nowhere, even though we've known about it for a while. And then also we're going to talk about the Kraken IPO and evaluation of that. And then also, lastly, Coinbase announced December 17th as a date. So they did an announcement of an announcement,
David:
[4:05] And then we get the leaks the next day. So we're going to talk about that as well.
Ryan:
[4:09] On the week, Bitcoin is down. Give us the damage.
David:
[4:12] Yeah, we got to rip this bandaid off. Bitcoin is down 13% on the week. It's down 23% on the month. We are currently clocking in at just a smidge over $87. It's one of those, I think all crypto people that have been around long enough just know this kind of feeling where- This feels like the bear? You wake up in the morning, you check the prices, and they're down. And you just repeat that process for like a couple weeks or so. It's been feeling like it's been like that. Ether telling a very similar story. $2,800 for a single Ether, down 14% on the week. 30% on the one month. But, you know, Ryan, if you just zoom out and you go back to April, we're up a good 2x. 2x from April. So, you know, just zoom out.
Ryan:
[5:01] 2x for E, right? That's how down bad ETH holders were in April of this year. I think we like wicked down to like 1,400 or something. Yeah. That was 1,700. It was actually 1,400 in April.
David:
[5:13] Was that the tariff bottom? Was that what that was? Yes. That was the tariff bottom.
Ryan:
[5:17] So still up from there. But none of this feels very good, of course. Total crypto market cap, we are at 3.1 trillion.
David:
[5:25] 3.1. That is a low number. We were at, what were we at? 4.4 was the all-time high. Yeah.
Ryan:
[5:30] Yeah. Are you ready to call this? Is this a bear market in your mind?
David:
[5:35] I mean, at some point, as bear market becomes like a technical definition, and if you're just like down for two quarters in a row, then that's like a bear market. The sentiment.
Ryan:
[5:43] That's like a recession. I don't know. I feel like crypto has a different definition.
David:
[5:47] No, but the recession is the economy. A bear market is part of the market. Like I said, the indicator to me is like, there is downward momentum right now. If I can wake up and be like, I'm going to check my phone and I know the prices are lower and that's true and that happens on a reoccurring basis,
David:
[6:04] like I've been there before. And that's like all of the bear market years.
Ryan:
[6:07] Sure, so give me your feeling.
David:
[6:09] Yeah, the feeling is, it feels like a bear market. It feels like you're just getting punched in the gut repeatedly and you just don't sell because like, I'm not going to sell now. Like it already happens. But then it happens again.
Ryan:
[6:21] The only part that's missing from that, I think, is months of that feeling playing out. And then it's like after months, you're like, oh, bear market confirmed, right?
David:
[6:30] Yeah, it's too late to sell.
Ryan:
[6:32] We haven't been there for months yet. But I will say, so the drawdown on Bitcoin right now, it's about 31% below all-time high from the top. And ETH is about 43% off. So if this is not a bear market, this is quite the bear trap that is being set right now. There was a breaking event that happened last Friday when crypto took a tumble down and so did stocks. There's two reasons that markets broke downwards last friday david one was there's now some fed rate cut uncertainty okay so if you go to uh polymarket fed decision in december look at this look at this change yeah that
David:
[7:15] Has flipped yeah we flipped from a 25 bips decrease which was almost a sure thing according to polymarket a few um like a month ago and now we are flipped to no change, no change clocking in at 63% chance with a 25 bps decrease at a 35% chance when those things used to be inverted.
Ryan:
[7:34] That's right. So investors are just repricing in the odds of a December rate cut and that, you know, the odds have gone down.
Ryan:
[7:41] So they're pricing that in. And you're seeing that in Polymarket. Fed presidents are saying that they are concerned about persistent inflation, indicating that policy is likely to remain restrictive. All right. That kind of hit the markets last Friday.
David:
[7:54] Can we talk about how there's $130 million of volume on this market? That is a lot. That's a crazy amount. I mean, if you are a macro trader and you closely follow the Fed, you finally have a tool to directly trade on something that so many people pay attention to. So this particular market has got to be one of the highest product market fits of all prediction markets.
Ryan:
[8:19] Well, it's also something that you can use to hedge some of your other positions, right? When you get this level of volume. All right, so that was the first thing. That was the first thing. Also, it seems like over the last week, maybe starting last Friday, we are getting more AI bubble fears. And this has always been in the air. Tech and AI stocks weakening. So there was a sell-off in the NASDAQ last week. Actually, this was news earlier in the week. I think it was maybe Sunday I saw this break. Peter Thiel sells his entire NVIDIA stack.
David:
[8:51] Dude, he just market sold NVIDIA?
Ryan:
[8:54] Mm-hmm. $100 million worth. Yep. This was 40%, one of his funds, of one of his funds' portfolio. And SoftBank sold as well. I'm not sure if this is sort of you're looking at prices and then you're you're looking for explanations to determine the price but this felt like a amplifier effect on the the perception of an ai bubble i'm seeing this everywhere in mainstream media is ai in a bubble is ai in a bubble you know it seems like it's in the air it's
David:
[9:24] One of those things where if there were more bullish news or if people were just less sketched out then no one would care about this but the fact that it
David:
[9:34] coincides with downside price movements with the Fed funds thing. Once people are bearish, bearishness can get more contagious. And we wouldn't care if this happened under different contexts.
Ryan:
[9:45] That's right. But I will say, David, Peter Thiel may have timed this wrong. So he may have sold too early because yesterday, Jensen, the CEO of NVIDIA,
David:
[9:57] Came out. The man who can't miss.
Ryan:
[9:59] Yeah. He saved the market. He saved AI. That's what people are saying. So this is Jensen. And so he comes out. The first thing Jensen says on the earnings report call, the context of all investors are looking for NVIDIA earnings as a bellwether for where the AI market is going. And keep in mind, do you know NVIDIA is 8% of the S&P right now?
David:
[10:20] 8%.
Ryan:
[10:21] 8%. Okay.
David:
[10:22] That's nuts.
Ryan:
[10:23] So it matters a lot. Very first thing Jensen says in the earnings call is he addresses the bubble. He says, there's been a lot of talk about the AI bubble. Here's what we're seeing at NVIDIA. And then he goes in and he just nails All earnings expectations. So it comes in, head revenue, comes in, head profit, just absolutely blows it out of the water. And we get a nice green candle in after-hours market of NVIDIA.
David:
[10:51] That is nuts. $187 to $195, $200 billion of market cap in a single move. That's a third of Ethereum.
Ryan:
[11:00] Yeah, a third of Ethereum in a single move, right? So Jensen's basically saying, hey, you've heard a lot of talk about the AI bubble. That's not what we're seeing. Here's the numbers to prove it. And by the way, we have forecasts of demand. So that's maybe staved.
David:
[11:14] Aren't they selling the picks and shovels to the perceived bubble? So they would make money whether it's a bubble or whether it's not a bubble either way.
Ryan:
[11:22] Well, they'll stop making money when demand slows. And part of a more recent AI narrative bubble is demand is starting to slow. Okay, we're over-provisions. We can't get the energy and electricity we need to actually power these data centers. So the chips are left sitting idle. They can't even be plugged into this apparatus. I mean, there's lots of different stories around this, of course. So anyway, all of those bad vibes last Friday, they were amplified in crypto. And David, we're at the point on the fear and greed index of extreme fear in
Ryan:
[11:56] crypto right now. All right?
David:
[11:58] It feels like in the trad market, there are both bears and bulls. And they're at least like kind of counterbalancing each other. Right. There's fear and there's greed in the trad market. And in crypto, it's just fear. It's just fear. We don't get any of the good stuff. We only have the bad stuff.
Ryan:
[12:13] Yep. Extreme fear. The last time we felt this, this cycle, was in April. And that was on the tariff here.
David:
[12:20] That was the bottom.
Ryan:
[12:22] Yeah, that was the bottom.
David:
[12:23] That's right. That was the bottom. That's right.
Ryan:
[12:25] The bottom, but not the end of the cycle. Correct. Key milestone, though, is Bitcoin had a death cross.
Ryan:
[12:30] Are you familiar with your TA, David? Do you know what a death cross is?
David:
[12:34] Yeah, it's like when the simple moving average crosses over some other line. It's just like two trends that cross. It's like the local trend crosses down below the long-term trend, which means that we are just not able to sustain a high enough price. And actually we have gone down a little bit. And so it's like a TA indicator to say like, oh, it's just a momentum thing. It's just like there has been enough momentum to the downside. But when we asked about Ledger about this, or actually it was actually maybe Ben Cowan as well. It's like once the death cross happens, you know, either you think that it's going to be more momentum to the downside, kind of what I was talking about with like, you know, week after week and month after month of just like negative prices or the negative prices have already been expressed. And like, it's already tracking the last two to three months of negative price action. And that's why the death cross happened. So how useful is this metric? I don't really know. It does tell you trends.
Ryan:
[13:29] Yeah, or maybe it doesn't tell you anything at all, to your point.
David:
[13:32] And even on this chart, you can see the last death cross that happened in like June of 2025. And then the one that happened before that, which was maybe October 2024. And the one that happened before that, which is somewhere around October 2023. And all of the thing that happened next was that it just rocketed up.
Ryan:
[13:50] Yeah, yeah, yeah. So this is the death cross is the 50-day simple moving average crossing below the 200-day. And like you said, sometimes it tells us it's over. Sometimes it doesn't, right? And so we've already had, what, you know, one, two, three, three death crosses already this cycle. And if you look at this chart- They were bullish.
David:
[14:09] The next thing that happened was it went up.
Ryan:
[14:11] Sure. So you can have bullish death crosses where it's good to buy the dip and you can have bearish ones, right? This is one year later, all the death crosses we've seen for Bitcoin in history, okay? And sometimes you get a 666% return one year later. And other times you get a negative 50% return one year later.
David:
[14:30] So you're telling me that there's no information here.
Ryan:
[14:33] Maybe not. But it does feel bad that Bitcoin is below 90K. It does feel bad. This is the first time in seven months where actually we've erased all of our 2025 gains. Look at the yearly candles here. It's just everything in 2025 is gone. All of our hard work. What happened? DATs aren't looking good either. Ethereum DATs. DATs are looking bad. DAT hangover. Yeah. Even the King DAT, right? Which is Michael Saylor's strategy is looking kind of bad. MNAV is, I don't know if it's below one right now. I probably should have looked at that, but it's really close. If it's not below one, it's just hanging above one. But the good news is David, Michael Saylor says he is still buying. This is Michael Saylor. Michael, given where Bitcoin's trading right now, are you buying? We are buying. We're buying quite a lot, actually. And we'll actually report our next buys on Monday morning. I think people will be pleasantly surprised. In fact, we've been accelerating our purchases. Are you ever not buying, Michael? No, we're always buying. There you go. Michael Saylor. He's never not buying.
David:
[15:37] No, we are always buying. Michael Saylor, just carrying the torch.
Ryan:
[15:42] Let me give you three perspectives that I've been reading on where we are in the market from different investors. And I think each of these like crypto investors and each of these have a slightly different take on things. The first is Raoul Paul. All right. Raoul Paul has been an extended cycle bull. He basically thinks it's not over. It will go into 2026. And he's maintaining this even after kind of the recent pullback. And he wanted to remind everyone. So he put out this tweet. I wanted to put the current sell off in perspective. Bitcoin corrected in 2024, negative 32%. In 2025, negative 32%. And right now is around 28%. We just updated that. It's about 31%. You've lived it before. We've already seen this, this cycle. Then he gives the numbers for Solana and Sui. We've already seen this. He says, technicals are flamboyantly oversold. Sentiment is in the shitter too. Worst I've seen this cycle. And his underlying message is, the cycle's not over. Don't F it up. It's probably not over, is where Raoul Paul leans. Arthur Hayes, he believes in the extended cycle as well. But rather than sort of hold through these 30% corrections, you know, he's a traitor. So he put out this post called Snow Forecast.
David:
[16:58] He has the best titles. I know, he does.
Ryan:
[17:00] It's a great, always great narrative around this and, you know, great intros. But he's basically saying his indicators, he's seeing some liquidity tightening. And this aligns, while you're out, David, I had a conversation with Michael Howell. He's the guy that basically invented this metric, the Global Liquidity Index. That episode comes out on Monday. You can see this at the end, this tip here, where global liquidity is kind of cresting and now it's going down? It's going down a little bit?
David:
[17:26] Well, a little bit. It doesn't really look like it's going down.
Ryan:
[17:29] But it's marginal, right? And so this marginal little bit liquidity dip, there's all sorts of reasons why, TGA accounts and all of this that we don't have time to get into, but we're seeing a liquidity dip. And so Arthur Hayes says this is impacting markets. And his basic take is that we're going to go down, Bitcoin can dump as low as 80K, stocks down 10 to 20%. And then what's going to happen is the Fed and Trump and Treasury are going to have to react and restart the markets. And so he expects things to go down. But then in 2026, it's up only. And what we're going to do first is we're going to retrace all of the gains since April. And then we're going to go back to up only once the money printer turns on again. So he's calling for a raging 2026 bull market fueled by this money printing. and also China QE too.
David:
[18:22] Okay, the reason why I didn't have a comment after Raoul Paul, because I also wanted to hear Arthur Hayes, but both of these two individuals, who I respect and who know more than me, tend to always think these things. Arthur Hayes always loves to back into QE is happening. And this is why the government is going to have to do QE and then we're going to rip. That is like the conclusion of like most Arthur Hayes' articles.
Ryan:
[18:49] And I'd also add, he's also trading it, right? So he sold a bunch of crypto too. I should say that. He's selling it. He sold a whole bunch for this dip, and then he's going to buy back lower. That's his plan. It's funny how everyone in crypto tends to play their character class, right? Raoul Paul is going to be forever bullish, bullish on the cycle, always bullish.
David:
[19:08] Raoul Paul is forever bullish.
Ryan:
[19:09] Arthur Hayes, he's a trader, so what is he doing? He's long-term bullish, but he's trading these dips, trading this cycle.
Ryan:
[19:15] There's a third take I want to throw in here, which is I would argue actually he's been the most accurate so far, which is our own friend of the show, Michael Nato from the DeFi report.
David:
[19:26] I have not known Michael Nato to have a bit, whereas Raoul Paul and Arthur Hayes both have bits. I don't know. I haven't had enough data from Michael Nadeau, but I have not identified a bit with Michael Nadeau, which makes me trust him a little bit more.
Ryan:
[19:42] Yeah, his bit is probably like on-chain financials and making sure to kind of, like fundamentals, I should say, and making sure to kind of trade these things.
David:
[19:50] Yeah, but that's not a bit. That's just being an analyst.
Ryan:
[19:52] Well, what he's saying is, so his bit is being an analyst. I don't know. He's not trying to sell a... A Twitter persona, let's say. Yes, that's correct. In the way that some of these others are. All right. So he says, basically, the cycle's probably over, may not be. I'll give you the silver line in a second. The reason is because Bitcoin has dropped below the 50-week moving average. Talked about this in the last two roll-ups of this being important. If we close below the 50-week moving average, every time we've done that in a fourth year, it's been over, David. And we are below that. See this blue line here? That's the 50-week moving average. It's about $103K, something like that. And we are well below $103K.
David:
[20:32] We are well below it.
Ryan:
[20:33] Two closes in a row, that's always indicated the end of the market. And he's still a cycle believer. And the reason he's a cycle believer is a little bit different than Raoul Paul and Arthur Hayes. It's basically he thinks these cycles are driven by holder activity. Long-term holders selling. The story is long-term holders have been selling. And you can see this in the on-chain data. They've primarily sold over 100k and it takes a while for the market to kind of reprice this but this is why cycles effectively end the only silver lining here for him is if bitcoin can reclaim that 50-week moving average hold as support the bull market can stay intact he said if price is rejected at this level it will reinforce the view the market structure is broken and we've got a longer more durable bear market beginning. So the three takes there, I guess you can pick which one you like from all of those.
Ryan:
[21:27] Nick Carter had to take on vibes, though, because that's another element of this.
David:
[21:31] I think Nick Carter is just kind of diagnosing the malaise that crypto feels because there is a lot of wealth being made outside the crypto markets. So Mag7, AI, any sort of AI stock, CoreWeave, NVIDIA, Microsoft, pick any AI stock, and you've made a lot of money in the traditional stock market. And that has not been the case in crypto, except for a few idiosyncrasies. Why is that? And so Nick Carter says 2025 is unironically worse because in 2022, bad things were happening, but crypto was a center of action and the star of the show. So even despite Three R's Capital, despite Sam Bankman Free, despite Terra Luna, crypto was nonetheless in the limelight. We were still the cool new thing. And so he says, you could describe negative price action to catalysts that you knew we were going to work through we were going to work through ftx and terraluna and all that stuff he continues and says now crypto is a forgotten child and with ai and the mag 7 starring retail is focused on data centers quantum and rare earth stocks crypto is trending down based on no catalyst just exhaustion and a lack of attention and buyers and the long dat hangover does this mean it's over no just a four-year cycle and alt season are obsolete concepts. To make money, you actually have to deliver value, which is a grim prospect to many. I think this is indicative of the maturing of crypto.
David:
[22:54] Like the vaporware infra meme coin tokens that have been like the casino of a lot of crypto behavior is the what he's saying is like the energy there is just gone and so you actually have to invest in correctly you have to allocate capital correctly and that's actually way harder than the crypto market has ever presented the average investor in its entire time uh and because we just don't have the limelight whenever there's because like the stock market is also suffering because of the Federal Reserve, potentially not cutting BIPs. But this crypto market is suffering way worse because we're their forgotten child. We're the child under the staircase.
Ryan:
[23:34] I think that's a decent explainer for sure. I also think, David, there's still some possibility that there's a dead body in the water from 1010 and somebody liquidated really bad and we just haven't seen that yet. Maybe that's a conspiracy take. But all this to say, if this is the end of the cycle, it's a super weird cycle. And we never reached the bull market euphoria of cycles past.
David:
[23:57] Which was never guaranteed.
Ryan:
[23:58] It was never guaranteed. But that also makes me think during the bear market, we're not going to reach the despair that we felt in previous bear markets, all right? This might be total pattern recognition, but it's usually if you have peak euphoria, then you get troughs of despair. And if we haven't had peak euphoria, I think this will, if we are in the bear market, this will be like a slow apathy type grind, bleed out over time, not despair. And I don't think we'll go as low as previous. We won't get poor,
David:
[24:26] We just will get bored.
Ryan:
[24:29] It's a good way to sum it up. All right, coming up next, we got DevConnect. What are the main themes? We're talking about Ethereum getting back to the layer one, privacy, there's a Vitalik keynote. David, you got to update me on the Bankless Summit. Also, Aave, the app, we'll talk about that. And is Aztec the Zcash of Ethereum? All this and more, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible.
David:
[24:49] So as we chatted about in the beginning, I am reporting live from the streets of Buenos Aires, where around 10,000 people are here to visit DevConnect. DevConnect and DevCon are the two events that the Ethereum Foundation throws about once a year. DevConnect is kind of supposed to be this inside-out event where they just kind of pick a place and they say, hey, we're going here at this time. Everyone make your events happen. In addition to that, they are also doing the DevCon model as well, where there is a central conference venue, which is where Vitalik gave his keynote speech, along with a few others. Tamash, the co-executive director of the EF, gave a talk. Xiaowei gave a talk. and a few others, kind of just giving, A state of the nation, a state of the ecosystem, a state of Ethereum. Now, Ryan, I've got my takes about people's excitement and chatter and buzz about what people are excited about and focused here on the streets of BA, Buenos Aires. But I would love to know what it looks like from the internet side of things, where you are native to.
Ryan:
[25:47] I can't speak for the full internet, but maybe I can speak from my perspective. So I caught up with some of the videos and some of the slides, Vitalik's keynote, Onscar presentation, a number of things, Tamash's presentation. Something I was really looking for was the L1 scaling plan. Because a few months ago, this had been a big TBD for me. I understand kind of the three-pillar focus of the Ethereum Foundation. One of those is scale L1. But I didn't know what the plan actually was, what the execution plan actually was. And what I saw from demophore was an emphasis on scaling the L1. It was almost like back to L1 scaling. So from Vitalik's keynote, he talked about L1 scaling in 2026. In 2026, he said, we will have a series of EIPs that will enable the Ethereum network to safely handle larger scales while maintaining decentralization, the ability to run regular nodes. He's talking about the roadmap here. And then that was followed up by Onsgar, who gave this presentation at
Ryan:
[26:54] The Bankless Summit. And he talked about the plan to go from 10x to 100x to 1000x, right? And concretely what this means and his take, his personal goal is that we can do a 10x in the next two years. So this keeps us on track for the 3x gas increases for the layer one in 2026. And really the calendar year is like this kind of started in 2025, mid 2025. So by mid 2026, we'll have our first 3x. He thinks that we can maintain that. And then eventually to get to the 1000x, you have to go to lean Ethereum and Justin Drake's roadmap. Anyway, that combination, maybe I'm sort of seeing what I want to in this, but Vitalik's keynote, Onscar, Tamash, there does seem to be a focus on L1 scaling again, and more of a concrete plan. Of course, for me, it's always like, all right, believe it when we see the execution. But Fusaka coming up, that's going to raise the gas limit from 45 to 60 million, which is a step in that direction, right? Step towards the 3X. So we're starting to see it and it's starting to become more real for me and make more sense. So that was my big takeaway, but it was also the primary thing I was looking for.
David:
[28:08] Yeah, I think the market really wants to look for that Ethereum layer one scaling plan. And if you were watching all of the talks that opened up DevConnect, you definitely could have found that stuff. The last DevCon was in Bangkok about a year ago. And at that time, the theme was something along the lines of we need to get layer twos to stage two. I think if I teleported back in time, that would have been like the major focus. In the morning talks, the talks that we're referencing, there was definitely a slide from Vitalik that was like, The Ethereum layer two roll-up centric map is working. Base has significantly scaled. We even have LIDAR now, which is massively scaled. And so the whole thesis of layer two scaling is working. And there was a dedicated slide for that. If you just counted the number of times that we talked about in the opening slides, the opening talks, layer twos versus scaling the layer one, scaling the layer one would have been a 10x number of instances versus the discussions around layer twos. And so if we take this as an indication of the EF's focus, we are currently shifting emphasis to talking about the scaling plan. You're totally right. Granted, we've talked about layer twos plenty over the last three or four years. The one thing you're missing, Ryan, that I will add was the Ethereum interop layer was introduced at this DevConnect. And that is a key feature of the Ethereum's third track, which is improve UX.
David:
[29:34] Which is an attempt to make Ethereum feel like one seamless experience rather than a bunch of fragmented layer twos. I have not had the time to go in and do my homework on the technical details of the Ethereum interrupt layer, but that is basically Ethereum's, the EF's coordination around the standards that it needs to take to allow layer twos to be a seamless experience. And that was actually shipped at this conference. And so that was pretty cool. I would definitely add that to some of your takeaways. And then in addition to that, there is a large amount of talk about what the scaling plan is. And so I think that is becoming culturally absorbed, incepted into the Ethereum enthusiast audience, which is the people who go to DevConnect. And so there's a lot of education about what this looks like. And I am now looking for, let me see what it actually looks like to take steps down that path. So I'm still in a little bit of a prove, don't tell, but there is certainly
David:
[30:30] a lot of telling, which is the first step to prove it. So I would agree with that and add those details as well.
Ryan:
[30:38] Yeah, I'm really looking for like a 3x gas increase in the next 12 months. And that's kind of the show me type thing.
David:
[30:44] Apologies to the presenter who I'm forgetting the name of, but there was also about maybe 10 to 12 minutes of time on the main stage in front of everyone talking about what it looks like to reduce block times in Ethereum,
David:
[30:57] like what happens, why that's a technical challenge and how we need to get there. And so getting down to six seconds as a near to medium term goal was also given a lot of airtime at the main event, which was very nice to see.
Ryan:
[31:10] That was my big takeaway. I know another thing that surfaced was a lot of talk about privacy. I think there was a separate event dedicated towards privacy that Vitalik spoke at. But what else was interesting to you? Like what are your on the ground takeaways?
David:
[31:24] My big themes are kind of like what I said, scaling the layer one has been said 10 times more than just talk about around layer twos, which is not to say the layer twos are forgotten. It's just like we're starting to approach, you know, mission accomplished with the layer twos, especially with the introduction of the intrap layer. Like you said, privacy being discussed with increased emphasis. Danny Ryan's talk on the main stage talked about the fact that there's massive product market fit between decentralization and institutions. And Ethereum has that. But what Ethereum does not have is privacy and how institutions need privacy. So there's a lot of chatter around privacy. I did a panel with Stephen from Arbitrum, Anton from OneInch, and then also Stani from Aave. And we kind of talked about what's next for DeFi. And a lot of them, basically the theme was they are all bending their products to fit within TradFi's needs. And Stephen Goldfeder gave a really interesting take on privacy, which is that institutions aren't looking for massive cypherpunk levels of privacy. They are looking for a level of privacy that you would expect to have from your fintech or bank, which is you don't have any privacy with the company that is giving you the product. Like they just know what your account balances are and that's fine.
Ryan:
[32:38] You just can't see it publicly on Etherscan.
David:
[32:40] Yes, you just can't see what your friend's account balances are. And so that kind of privacy is something that it seems like Arbitrum is working on with institutions to help develop or something along those lines. That's what the institutions are looking for from Arbitrum. I would also say that one big takeaway that I had coming out of the Bankless Summit and a few other places as well is some of Ethereum's deep research is turning into app layer enhancements and is kind of now applications' responsibility to learn how to leverage them. This is talking about real-time ZK proving. Ethereum has invested in, zk proving as a as a vertical for years and that has now hit mainnet brevis has products online zk succinct has products online these can all enhance a lot of what we do on defy and we have these tools now like the the fruits of these investments are born and it's now up to apps to pick them so that was a big takeaway uh kind of going back to the main stage stuff one big sentiment that was hammered into uh the audience which was again crypto ethereum enthusiasts is this notion of we need to be real. One line from, I think, Onsgar's talk was, if you can't explain what your job is in crypto, then you should be concerned. You should be able to explain to your mom what your job is.
Ryan:
[33:57] Oh, shit. Does podcaster count or no? Yes.
David:
[34:00] Okay. I think that's pretty easy.
Ryan:
[34:02] It doesn't seem like a real job, though.
David:
[34:06] It's really just there was being this emphasis on a shift from future idealism to the here and now in Ethereum culture. Is, yeah, we love talking about the future, but also today is the day to go get product market fit because product market fit is out there and we need to go.
David:
[34:24] Stablecoins and neobanks I think everyone understands are this looming tidal wave that people know is coming but not everyone knows to do with it yet like this is a frontier that EtherFi is pushing that Frax is pushing and so understanding that Ethereum is the banking layer and you don't need banks anymore you just need neobanks to provide consumer endpoints that was a big topic of conversation and that's kind of inclusive of this like general pivot to fintech theme that I'll identify that some people will identify, which is also related to like how some infra tokens don't have their token generation event at evaluation nearly as high as they used to. So this is a tweet from Richard Chen, who's down here. And one last cultural thing, even though I just said that Ethereum is now reemphasizing its cultural idealism from the future to the now, in Tomas' talk and as well as in a few others, he opened up with, yo, the future is here. AI is here. Robots are here. There is the dystopian side of these technologies. In addition to all the value that we're getting, there are these dystopian side of these future technologies that are arriving here and now. And we need to remember how Ethereum is and has always tried to be a bulwark against future dystopian reality. So it's a combination of product market fit today, but also remember why we built Ethereum to be this like cypherpunk place of sovereignty to protect against future dystopia. And so it was a nice reminder.
Ryan:
[35:51] Okay, so overall, did you, are you, I know it's not done yet, but are you walking away from this bullish or neutral or bearish?
David:
[36:00] I would like some more time on that answer. We have two more days of DevConnect. And one further note about DevConnect is it's pretty fragmented by design. DevConnect is always meant to be like a bottom-up conference. And so everyone's kind of all over the place. So I would like to get a little bit more time and hear other people's takeaways. It's nice to hear all the talk about scaling the layer one. I would like to see that show up in EIPs that reduce latency and increase gas, either or. And so I would like to actually, maybe I'll turn that into an article, Ryan, that I will write about my takeaways from DevConnect because I need to go kind of collect some more data on that one.
Ryan:
[36:39] Okay. My feeling from afar was overall... Overall bullish. And the reason is because there seems to be this pivot towards the L1, which Ethereum definitely needed to do. And there seems to be an actionable, executable plan towards that. And then also, all the vibes that you just gave, feels like Ethereum is a bit more grounded, a less infinite garden vibey and more like DeFi. I did not hear
David:
[37:03] The words infinite garden at all during this conference.
Ryan:
[37:06] Very good. And I know the Bankless Summit went well. We probably don't have to get into all the details, but we've got a lot of sessions that are going to be on the Bankless Premium feed next week. And I know, I can't wait to hear this one. This is one on X402. Brevis, you said, gave a fantastic talk. Any other highlights from that that people can expect on the Bankless Premium feed?
David:
[37:26] Yeah, so that's going to come out starting at the end of this week and next week. Danny Ryan also told the story of him getting served at Thanksgiving.
Ryan:
[37:34] God, that was a rough,
David:
[37:36] Rough story.
Ryan:
[37:36] At Thanksgiving?
David:
[37:37] Yeah, at Thanksgiving. By the SEC. By the SEC, that's right, yeah. And then Luca from MZero gave, you know, Ryan, you and I like to talk about the theory and thesis of money. He gave a talk about money, like the bare bones about what makes a money a money from like a network standpoint. I think you're really going to like that one. MZero was our partner for the Bankless Summit, and they really just did a killer job. And so just shout out to MZero. So those, I think, are some of my favorites. It's Lucas, X402, Brevis's. Shay from Flashbots always does a killer job with the talk. That one was highly enjoyable. And yeah, so those are going to start to trickle out on the Bankless Premium feed shortly.
Ryan:
[38:16] That's a lot to catch up on for your Thanksgiving holidays.
David:
[38:18] 12 episodes. 12 episodes, 20 minutes each.
Ryan:
[38:21] Yes. Oh my God. Speaking of...
David:
[38:25] Speaking of what, Ryan?
David:
[38:29] Speaking of the Aave app, Aave has introduced the Aave app, which is, call it a Neobank. You download the Aave app. I believe it's on iOS and Android. You can join the waitlist today. And it's a very polished, very sexy place to deposit money and get yield on your stables. So up to 6.5% APY. You just wire money in with Plaid. You don't see blockchains.
Ryan:
[38:53] I love that Aave is doing this. Very cool.
David:
[38:55] Yes. If you recognize the USCC and the Tether logos and you understand that those are stable coins, but no facet of a token or a blockchain is ever presented to you, which is just great. Interest compounded every second, which I think is very necessary in the era of very short-term attention spans and the needs for instant gratification. And then some kind of like back-end engineering, like the auto saver from Abe moves money from a linked bank account to the Abe app automatically and then kind of rebalances.
Ryan:
[39:26] Oh, one last thing we got to say on this. A balance protection, okay? Up to potentially.
David:
[39:31] A million dollars of insurance on deposits. Right. Wow. Wow.
Ryan:
[39:36] So this is something like,
David:
[39:37] Okay, remember Anchor Protocol? The thing that blew up Terra Luna and got so much adoption. Why are you.
Ryan:
[39:43] Referring to that right now?
David:
[39:44] Because it was the same thing. All good products in crypto are front run. By two to four years of a scam that came before it.
Ryan:
[39:54] You're saying Anchor promised these things, did not deliver these things or something? Yeah, it was like- Anchor did not have insurance. Those people got wrecked.
David:
[40:01] That's exactly my point. They were like, Anchor was like, to come deposit your money, we'll transfer it into stable coins and we'll get you yield. And Aave is saying the same thing. The difference is, Anchor was paying out 20%, totally unsustainable yield, and it blew up. And Aave is like, okay, $1 million insurance, yields dictated by the market, which are high, by the way, at 6.5%. And so this is finally the, and the point I'm trying to make is that Anchor did a fantastic job getting a lot of money.
Ryan:
[40:29] Of onboarding retail to a scam.
David:
[40:31] Of onboarding people into a scam. Yeah. Now we have some actual polished professionals who have been here, And they're fulfilling that same promise of, yo, come save in crypto, save in crypto. And we're doing it with a million dollars of insurance. We don't have the details of how the insurance works.
Ryan:
[40:49] I know, I definitely want to see what the details are.
David:
[40:52] I want to see what the details are, but that's nonetheless probably a very important hurdle to like opening up the TAM for deposits into Aave. So congratulations to the Aave team.
Ryan:
[41:01] It certainly is for me before referring friends because when you have like DeFi hacks and that kind of thing, If you go send this to a friend and one day they wake up and they're like, hey, David, all my money's gone. Where did it go?
David:
[41:14] All the money that you told me to put into Anchor is gone.
Ryan:
[41:16] Exactly. Not Anchor, but I would never do that.
David:
[41:20] I think this is just the foot in the door for Aave. Because you can't really do that much. You can put your stables in and you can get some yield. This product has to evolve from here to really be market competitive. It's a fantastic foot in the door. I'm sure they have phase 2, phase 3, phase 4 lined up at some point in the future Sure.
Ryan:
[41:40] But even now, 6% yield 6.5 Yeah, what bank account can compete with that?
Ryan:
[41:46] David, we also have another release Aztec takes a big step towards mainnet This is the tweet, Aztec just shipped the ignition chain the first fully decentralized L2 on Ethereum Aztec has been around forever Forever? They've been promised a private layer two essentially and they've been building this over the years kind of watching them now they're finally getting closer to launching towards mainnet i kind of think that this is ethereum's answer to zcash actually because it's i
David:
[42:17] Don't know if ethereum needs an answer to.
Ryan:
[42:20] Zcash it needs an answer for privacy right there's there's clear true clear product market fit to have private block space and a private store of value on that block space, which is essentially what Zcash is. And if you can take your ETH store of value and you can bridge that to Aztec and you have the entire smart contract landscape of DeFi and everything else on Aztec and your store of value, then you're accomplishing in the Ethereum ecosystem the exact same thing as Zcash, except you don't have to, this is how Amin Soleimani put it, you don't have to buy the Zcash Ponzi scheme. What he means is you don't have to buy a separate store of value asset, basically Zcash.
David:
[43:03] Amin uses the term Ponzi scheme, I think, endearingly. He will also call Bitcoin.
Ryan:
[43:08] Ether, they're all kind of pyramid schemes.
David:
[43:11] All store of values are, we use these terms way too lightly, Ryan. What we mean is in the same way gold is in the same exact category.
Ryan:
[43:21] They're confidence games. They're confidence assets.
David:
[43:23] Yeah. Yes. Whatever. Confidence assets.
Ryan:
[43:25] People understand, but I hope they do. Maybe they don't. You're right. Anyway. Okay. This is a step towards mainnet. So they're not mainnet yet. This is what was somewhat confusing.
David:
[43:34] But blocks are being produced.
Ryan:
[43:35] Blocks are being produced. This is like their beacon chain. You remember when Thierry watched the beacon chain and you could validate on it, but you couldn't like actually use it. This is what they're doing. But when I say validating, what I mean is actually you could stake in the network, you're a sequencer, all right? Because the consensus layer happens all on Ethereum because this is layer two, but they have completely decentralized their sequencer, which is a first for an L2, all right? Which is incredible. They've got 500 sequencers out there. And so that's what you're doing.
David:
[44:08] I think it's very important for Aztec, a privacy chain to have shipped with a decentralized sequencer set on day one.
Ryan:
[44:14] Of course, that's why they're doing it. And so when you're in there, it's DeFi, it's smart contracts, it's all of the things.
David:
[44:20] Now, that stuff has to be built. This is the most cypherpunk thing to have launched in so long.
Ryan:
[44:24] It's really cool. It's really cool. Now, okay, mainnet doesn't happen until a projected date of audits being complete by February, 2026. So we could be a beacon chain. You could be a sequencer if you want. There's also, they're doing a public coin offering as well. So you could buy some Aztec tokens.
David:
[44:42] Token sale meta. I love the token sale meta. That feels like we are at the end game of token distribution mechanisms, which is a sale.
Ryan:
[44:51] Yes. And then he can use the chain in February, 2026. So a long time coming, but it looks like it's here.
Ryan:
[44:57] David, coming up next, Coinbase leaks a screenshot. What has that shown us? It's maybe an early Christmas gift.
David:
[45:03] Well, they don't leak this screenshot, but somebody does.
Ryan:
[45:04] No, they didn't. Somebody figured this out. Kraken IPO, what's the valuation? Also, CZ, the CZ case was on, pardon case, Trump pardon, remember that, was on 60 Minutes. And El Salvador is buying the Bitcoin dip, all that and more. But before we do.
David:
[45:21] $800 million raised by Kraken to advance their strategic roadmap. This is probably the last big step that they are going through in order to go public. This round was led by investors from Jane Street, Oppenheimer Alternative Investment Management. Wow, that is a name. And also Tribe Capital. And then Citadel Securities, interestingly, joined as a strategic investor with a $200 million investment. The goals of this race is so that they can expand into regions like Latin America, the Asia-Pacific, and EMEA. I don't know what the EMEA is. What is that? I don't know. And also they want to expand their product offerings. So including equity trading, tokenized assets, and new payment solutions. So everyone kind of going into a super app of securities, tokenization, and payment rails. I think we can see many different corners of crypto all kind of moving there. At the same time, they file for an IPO inside the United States. So they have confidentially filed for a U.S. IPO. What does it mean to be a confidential filing? it means that they don't have to disclose all their inner workings. It doesn't mean that they're secretly filing. It means they just don't have to disclose stuff.
David:
[46:31] And so it doesn't specify the share count, offering size, or the timing. But we do know some things. Kraken had $1.5 billion of revenue in 2024. It has diversified some of its offerings through acquisitions. Ninja Trader, Small Exchange, which were Kraken acquisitions in 2024, have helped Kraken expand into TradFi and derivatives. and then most people, most reports are suggesting that Kraken aims for a public listing in Q1, 2026. Hopefully, the IPO window is still open by then. I hope so.
Ryan:
[47:04] The rumor is about 20 billion for the IPO. So it's kind of interesting if you think about US, primarily US-based exchanges, crypto exchanges. Now you gotta put Robinhood in the mix there now, Coinbase, and then Kraken would be a strong number three here. And what if you compare the valuations? Who knows what Robinhood is right now 90 billion
David:
[47:25] Coinbase is 90.
Ryan:
[47:27] Billion okay
David:
[47:28] Yeah. Robinhood, I think, is somewhere like $120 or $130 or something.
Ryan:
[47:32] Okay. Okay. So this would be well under those amounts. And maybe this could be a reasonable IPO price for Kraken. Speaking of Coinbase, David, maybe an early Christmas gift that Coinbase is going to offer. So you mentioned in the intro, this unveiling Coinbase's promise for the 17th. Well, there are some screenshots. I use the term leaked, but these actually haven't been leaked. So somebody was sleuthing Coinbase public code and they reverse engineered the public code and came up with these screenshots. All right. So this is Jane Wong here.
David:
[48:07] This is a screenshot, but it's a slip. Is that what this is?
Ryan:
[48:11] Well, the code kind of leaked, right? And then somebody, you know, you put the code together and put some screenshot. Anyway, the screenshot shows stocks in the Coinbase interface and So you could trade stocks, right? You know, they have the trading button for all your crypto assets and then also stocks and also prediction market. So Kalshi integration.
David:
[48:30] No surprise whatsoever. It's lovely to see them do this, but yeah, Coinbase is doing prediction markets. They have to do that.
Ryan:
[48:40] And they're not officially doing all of this yet, but that could be the release that they're going to be dropping on December 17th. So be a one-stop shop for everything in crypto.
David:
[48:51] I think a lot of people who are paying attention to the Kalshi-Polymarket wars are going to notice the Kalshi integration. You'll be like, why isn't Kalshi-Polymarket? Because Kalshi-Polymarket is the crypto-native version. Why aren't we doing the crypto-native stuff? It's because Kalshi has the United States regulations, which Kalshi-Polymarket does not.
Ryan:
[49:07] 60 Minutes. So Trump's Pardon was a feature in a TV show, 60 Minutes. Do you ever watch 60 Minutes? Do your parents watch this growing up or anything? No.
David:
[49:16] No.
Ryan:
[49:16] All right. It comes on every Sunday. It's very old school journalism, right? Anyway, they did a whole 13 to 15 minute segment on CZ's pardon in talking, linking that to Trump corruption. So they reported that President Trump's pardon of CZ was highly controversial. There were conflicts of interest. Basically, they were talking about his stable coin and let's see, Binance's stable coin injection into World Liberty Finance. and basically saying that this is all an example of corruption. It was funny as I was watching this. I just wanted to get caught up on the clip. And up pops Austin Campbell.
David:
[49:54] Oh, we like Austin. I love how Austin's hair always looks crazy, and he has clearly done an effort to comb his hair and make it look less crazy, and it still looks very crazy.
Ryan:
[50:06] Yeah. Anyway, this is some of the mainstream narrative that's been coming out. And I also combine this with, because I've been watching basically the political reaction to crypto, and I think we're in store for somewhat of a backlash coming soon, right? We've made tremendous progress in crypto, but it feels like a backlash could be coming. I read this essay in The Atlantic. It's entitled, How Crypto Could Trigger the Next Financial Crisis. Nick Carter actually tweeted this out. Yeah, so let me see if you recognize the person that wrote this. His name is David Frum. I know you listen to the Sam Harris podcast. He's been a guest on Sam Harris.
David:
[50:44] Oh, has he?
Ryan:
[50:45] Yeah, so he has a show he had Sam Harris on, The Rise of Technofascists. That's kind of a theme for David Frum, right? So he's covering this. He's a journalist, a political commentator. And he's kind of linking Trump corruption, basically, to crypto and techno-fascism. Okay? And that's his entire take. So he wrote this take.
David:
[51:08] Well, what do you mean that was his entire take? What's the actual mechanism for how crypto crashes the market?
Ryan:
[51:13] Okay. He was railing against stablecoins. He said, the promise of stablecoins is false. They're too dangerous to be used as a medium of exchange. No one uses stablecoins for payment.
David:
[51:23] Both of those statements are terrible.
Ryan:
[51:26] The only use of stables is for offshore funds to hold USD without submitting to KYC.
David:
[51:30] That's obviously not true.
Ryan:
[51:32] Tether is inventing a new coin that will be anti-KYC. DEXs mean that foreign non-genius regulated stablecoins can enter the US freely. What?
David:
[51:41] I guess, sure.
Ryan:
[51:43] Only bad actors will want to buy stablecoins. Stablecoins aren't backed by FDIC insurance. They're better than that because they're just treasuries.
David:
[51:51] They don't need to be backed by FDIC insurance because they're backed one-to-one.
Ryan:
[51:56] Yes. And there's the thing. Congress only passed Genius because of Trump's corruption or because they all collectively lost their minds. That's the only explanation. And so it's basically an example of something that is happening more and more, which is basically the political theory of, I think David Frum is doing this. Trump is bad. Trump likes stable coins. Therefore, stable coins are bad. And I'm going to rationalize all of the above with a set of one-dimensional arguments that's not actually looking at stable coins from first principle. That's the political backlash that I think is happening here.
David:
[52:29] I bet Elizabeth Warren loved this tweet.
Ryan:
[52:33] Yeah, I'm not sure she's reading up on Nick Hart, but I'm sure she reads the Atlantic.
David:
[52:38] The article, I guess, yes.
Ryan:
[52:39] That's in store for us, I think, sometime. David, there are some people, some entities, buying the Bitcoin dip. One of those is Harvard. Harvard has tripled down on its Bitcoin bet. It is buying so much of iBit, that's the Bitcoin BlackRock ETF, that they are the 16th largest holder Okay. So, yeah, IBIT is actually their largest equity position. I believe Harvard's, the Harvard endowment. And so Eric Balchunas says, this is a big deal. Just checked in and yeah, IBIT is now Harvard's largest position. It's biggest position increase in Q3. It's super rare to get an endowment to buy on an ETF, especially Harvard or Yale. It's as good a validation as an etf can get so they're buying the dip
David:
[53:26] Nice um not only harvard further countries well just the same country actually el salvador has made its largest single day bitcoin purchase it bought a thousand bitcoins uh when bitcoin fell to below ninety thousand dollars so it increased the country's total bitcoin holdings to seven thousand five hundred bitcoins well roughly valued, Just shy of $700 million. I remember, Ryan, last time we talked about El Salvador, there was a conflict with El Salvador and the IMF because they want funds from the IMF. And the IMF is like, okay, the only way that you get funds is if you just shut down your Bitcoin operations. You don't have to sell, but you can't do it anymore. You just got to stop. And I mean, they just bought a thousand Bitcoins. They bought $100 million in Bitcoins. It actually prohibits El Salvador. The IMF prohibits El Salvador from acquiring BTC. I don't know what they have to enforce it other than their $1.4 billion loan program. But we will see. There's a standoff between the IMF and Bukele.
Ryan:
[54:29] It's funny. Bukele just can't resist. He's just like, because the IMF, even there was an IMF report in July, I believe. And IMF said, oh, we've given El Salvador some loans. They're not buying new Bitcoin anymore since our $1.4 billion loan program. And here's Bukele like sneakily just buying.
David:
[54:49] I mean, like, I can kind of understand it because, well, what do you mean not with the same funds? If you get like a $1.4 billion loan from the IMF and then you go and spend that on the things that you said.
Ryan:
[55:00] With other money, David. No, no, no.
David:
[55:02] And then you just magically show up with $100 million to buy Bitcoin.
Ryan:
[55:08] Yeah, so I don't know what the IMF's reaction is,
David:
[55:10] But I do enjoy the audacity. Thank you.
Ryan:
[55:14] So David, some few things to round out this week. BlackRock filed for the staked Ethereum trust. So I think it's finally going to happen. We're going to have the staked Ethereum. Well, this is Ethereum trust, but we're going to get an ETF at some point, I'm sure. So that's happening.
David:
[55:30] We're closing in on it. We're closing in on it.
Ryan:
[55:33] I want to ask you this because this was something that was interesting this week. ETH is now exceeding as a percentage of network supply Bitcoin in treasury companies. All right. And this is totally unexpected.
Ryan:
[55:46] This was probably one of the most unexpected things starting 2025. I would have never believed to this. If you told me in 2025 that at the end of the year, the total amount of ETH supply in ETH treasury companies would exceed the total amount of Bitcoin and Bitcoin treasury companies, I would have never believed you. So that's kind of incredible. And yet, price is down. This is Hatsu's take. Interestingly, unlike Bitcoin, ETH is nowhere near all-time high. It feels like crypto-native investors are largely abandoning ETH as an investment, though not necessarily for building or using, while institutions and trad retail are filling the gap. What do you think of this take? Do you think that's what's going on?
David:
[56:28] This chart has a lot of story in it. In this chart, which is a chart of Bitcoin slowly grinding up to wherever it is, like a 3.5% of total Bitcoin inside of DAS, and then Ether just rockets up to 4.5% very quickly. You see the different ages of the network in this chart. It's easier for Ether to get to a higher number because it's got a lower market cap. Part of that story of that lower market cap is that Ethereum is a younger blockchain. And so synonymously, you also just see the lower market cap here. You also see the price malaise of ETH as well, because it's easier to accumulate a bunch of ETH when it's a lower price. And so there's a bunch of things baked into this graph. I don't know what signal, what story it says that Ether has more ETH in DAS as a percentage of its sole supply than Bitcoin. I don't really know what to
David:
[57:22] make of that. Don't focus on that.
Ryan:
[57:23] Though. What about this take, that Hasu's take, which is basically like, hey, it seems like institutional investors in TradFi kind of like ETH, right? ETF flows, DAT flows, that sort of thing. But crypto-native investors have somewhat abandoned it this cycle.
David:
[57:37] Yeah, I think, well, that's been the theme of the last like two years is Ethereum fragmentation is rough. The Ethereum layer one is not a good place to do a lot of the crypto-native stuff that's happened over the last year, which is meme coins. And so people have either gone up the stack to Bitcoin or down the stack to more risk on speculative casino type behavior. And so Ethereum has been in this tough spot. I think this is kind of just emblematic of some of the malaise that Ethereum has felt over the last two years.
Ryan:
[58:05] I agree. I think we'll get some of the crypto native investors back, but I don't know that we'll get them back this cycle. This might take some time to play out. Got to wrap it there, guys. This has been the weekly roll-up, of course. You know crypto is risky. I'm sure you feel that on weeks like this. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.