Glamsterdam's Gas Debate Heads to Thursday
Monday's testing call surfaced compatibility findings, though Ethereum core devs left the fate of EIP-8037 and EIP-8038 for Thursday's ACDE.
Ethereum core developers wrapped Monday's testing call without settling the future of EIP-8037 and EIP-8038. The two gas repricings make creating and touching onchain state pricier, so Glamsterdam's bigger blocks don't bloat the data every node has to store.
Next stop is ACDE #249, Thursday's execution-layer call at 9am ET on Nov. 19th.
What's the Scoop?
The findings: ChainSecurity's audit and the Ethereum Foundation's internal search together logged about 200 compatibility findings, per the call's summary. Auditor Dedaub also turned up 22 contracts the EF's study had missed.
Mostly price wrinkles: Most findings trace back to plain price increases, like contracts that hardcode a gas amount, rather than EIP-8037's new "reservoir" for tracking state gas. EF developer Marius van der Wijden put the exposure at roughly 10,000-15,000 of about 90M contracts, with a few hundred thousand dollars at risk.
Enjoying this article?
Subscribe to Bankless or sign in
Vitalik backs 8037: Separate from his leanPCS thread, Vitalik Buterin made the case for EIP-8037 on Sunday night. He warned that a 10x gas limit without it would push state growth from ~110 GiB a year to ~1,100 GiB, while acknowledging the change could break some apps, like bridges that hardcode gas limits.
The other side: Juicebox builder jango, whose simulations showed users skipping payments with a tuned gas limit, says Juicebox's live versions can't be fixed in place. Security researcher pcaversaccio has argued that staying compatible at the consensus level isn't the same as keeping apps working.
Thursday's options: Core devs could keep the specs as written, adopt an accounting fix, or pull EIP-8037 from Glamsterdam, though the EF's own timeline says "no decision is pre-committed." ChainSecurity's full public report is also still on the slate, and the Hoodi testnet fork, postponed in October, has no new date.
Quantum angle: Since Glamsterdam sits in front of Ethereum's post-quantum push, which proponents say will need more gas per transaction, a longer delay could ripple down the roadmap.